top of page
Writer's pictureThe Book Prose Team

The Ultimate Guide to Growing Your Author Newsletter

Updated: Oct 20

A woman in a sweater typing on a laptop

As an indie author, one of the most powerful tools in your marketing arsenal is your newsletter. It's a direct line to your readers, a way to build a loyal fan base, and a platform to promote your books without relying solely on social media algorithms or paid advertising. But how do you grow your newsletter from scratch? How do you turn it into a thriving community of engaged readers? This guide will walk you through every step of the process, from setting up your newsletter to advanced strategies for growth and engagement.


1. Understanding the Importance of an Author Newsletter


Before diving into the how-to, it's crucial to understand why an author newsletter is so important. Unlike social media platforms where algorithms control content visibility, emails land directly in your subscribers' inboxes. This direct access is invaluable for maintaining consistent communication with your audience.


Moreover, you own your email list. Unlike a social media following that can disappear if a platform changes its policies or shuts down, your email list remains yours. This ownership gives you more control and stability in your author platform.


Email marketing typically boasts higher conversion rates compared to social media marketing. When it comes to promoting your books or launching new titles, your newsletter subscribers are more likely to take action, whether that's purchasing a book or leaving a review.


Regular communication through your newsletter helps build stronger relationships with your readers. By sharing exclusive content, behind-the-scenes insights, and personal updates, you create a sense of connection that turns casual readers into devoted fans.


A newsletter offers versatility that few other marketing tools can match. You can use it for book launches, sharing writing updates, running promotions, or even serializing stories. This flexibility allows you to adapt your strategy as your author career evolves.


2. Setting Up Your Newsletter


The first step in your newsletter journey is choosing an Email Service Provider (ESP). Popular options include MailerLite, MailChimp, ConvertKit, and AWeber. When making your selection, consider factors such as:


Ease of use: Look for an intuitive interface that won't require a steep learning curve.

Pricing: Consider your budget and the features offered at different price points.

Automation features: These can save you time and help create sophisticated email sequences.

Integration capabilities: Ensure the ESP can integrate with your website platform and other tools you use.


Once you've selected your ESP, it's time to set up your account. This process typically involves creating an account, setting up your sender information (including your author name and a professional email address), and designing a basic template that reflects your author brand.


Your email template should be clean, easy to read, and mobile-responsive. Many ESPs offer customizable templates that you can adapt to suit your brand. Include your author logo if you have one, and choose colors that align with your website and book covers for brand consistency.


Next, focus on creating sign-up forms. These forms are crucial as they're the primary way readers will join your list. Design attractive, user-friendly forms that include fields for name and email address at minimum. Consider adding optional fields like genre preferences for future segmentation. Place these forms strategically on your website, including:


• In the header or footer of your site

• As a pop-up or slide-in form

• At the end of blog posts

• On a dedicated "Join My Newsletter" landing page


Remember, the easier you make it for readers to sign up, the more likely they are to do so.


3. Creating Compelling Sign-Up Incentives


To encourage readers to join your list, it's essential to offer a compelling incentive, often called a "lead magnet." This is something valuable you provide in exchange for a reader's email address. Effective lead magnets for authors might include:


• A free short story set in your book's world

• A prequel novella to your main series

• Exclusive bonus content like deleted scenes or character interviews

• A guide or resource related to your book's theme or setting


Whatever you choose, ensure your lead magnet is high-quality and genuinely useful or entertaining. It should give subscribers a taste of your writing style and leave them wanting more. This first impression can set the tone for your entire relationship with the subscriber, so make it count.


When promoting your incentive, highlight its value on your sign-up forms. Use enticing language like "exclusive," "free," and "limited time offer" to create a sense of urgency and value. Be clear about what subscribers will receive and how it will benefit them.


Consider creating multiple lead magnets for different segments of your audience. For example, if you write in multiple genres, you might have a different incentive for each. This allows you to tailor your offer to specific reader interests, potentially increasing your sign-up rate.


4. Optimizing Your Website for Newsletter Growth


Your website is a crucial tool for growing your newsletter, serving as the central hub for your author platform. Start by strategically placing sign-up forms throughout your site. Include a prominent form in your website's header or sidebar, ensuring it's visible on every page.


Consider adding a pop-up or slide-in form that appears after a certain time or scroll depth. While some people find pop-ups annoying, they can be highly effective when used judiciously. Set them to appear after a reader has engaged with your content for a while, rather than immediately upon landing on the page.


Don't forget to place a sign-up form at the end of blog posts. Readers who have just finished consuming your content are primed to want more, making this an ideal time to invite them to join your list.


Create a dedicated landing page for newsletter sign-ups. This page should focus solely on encouraging visitors to subscribe. Here, you can go into more detail about the benefits of joining your list and showcase your lead magnet. Use compelling copy that speaks directly to your ideal reader, highlighting what they'll gain by subscribing.


Remember to optimize for mobile users. With more people browsing on smartphones, a smooth mobile experience is essential for maximizing sign-ups. Ensure all sign-up forms are mobile-friendly and test the sign-up process on various devices.


Consider using content upgrades. These are lead magnets specific to a particular blog post or page. For example, if you have a blog post about world-building, you might offer a world-building worksheet as a content upgrade. This targeted approach can be highly effective in converting readers into subscribers.


5. Leveraging Social Media to Grow Your List


Social media platforms offer excellent opportunities to promote your newsletter and attract new subscribers. The key is to use these platforms strategically, always with the goal of driving traffic back to your website or sign-up page.


Regularly share snippets of exclusive content from your newsletter on your social media accounts. This gives followers a taste of what they're missing and can entice them to sign up. Post about your lead magnet and its benefits, using eye-catching graphics to grab attention in crowded social feeds.


Create a pinned post on Twitter, Facebook, and other platforms with a link to your sign-up page. This ensures that visitors to your profile immediately see your newsletter promotion, even if they don't scroll through your feed.


Each social media platform offers unique features you can leverage:


• On Facebook, add a newsletter sign-up button to your page. You can also use Facebook Live to engage with followers and promote your newsletter.

• On Instagram, include a link to your newsletter in your bio. Use Instagram Stories to share behind-the-scenes content and encourage viewers to swipe up to join your list.

LinkedIn can be particularly useful if you write non-fiction or business-related books. Use LinkedIn articles to showcase your expertise and include a call-to-action to join your newsletter.

• On TikTok, create short, engaging videos that offer value to viewers and end with a call-to-action to join your newsletter for more in-depth content.


Remember, the goal isn't to be on every platform, but to use a few strategically. Choose the platforms where your target readers are most active and focus your efforts there.


6. Using Your Books to Build Your Mailing List


Your books themselves are powerful tools for growing your mailing list. Every reader who picks up your book is a potential newsletter subscriber, so make sure you're taking full advantage of this opportunity.


Include a newsletter invitation at the end of your ebooks. This is prime real estate – readers who have just finished your book are at their most engaged and likely to want more from you. Make your invitation compelling by offering an exclusive bonus (like an epilogue or a short story featuring a beloved character) in exchange for signing up.


For print books, consider using QR codes that lead to your newsletter sign-up page. Place these on the back cover or in the back matter. QR codes make it easy for readers to sign up immediately using their smartphones, reducing the friction between interest and action.


Don't forget to promote your newsletter in your author bio on retailer sites like Amazon, Barnes & Noble, and Kobo. A brief mention of the benefits of joining your list can entice readers who've just finished your book and are looking for more of your work.


If you do public readings or book signings, have a sign-up sheet available for attendees to join your list. You can also create bookmarks or other promotional materials that include your newsletter information to hand out at events.


If you're able to include bonus content in the back of your books (especially common in ebooks), make sure this content is exclusive to newsletter subscribers. This creates a strong incentive for readers to sign up.


7. Collaborating with Other Authors


Collaboration can supercharge your list growth by exposing you to new audiences. Partner with authors in your genre for cross-promotions, offering a bundle of lead magnets from multiple authors. This exposes you to each other's audiences, potentially bringing in a flood of new subscribers.


Newsletter swaps are another effective strategy. In a newsletter swap, you mention another author's work or sign-up offer in your newsletter, and they do the same in theirs. This can be a win-win situation, helping both authors grow their lists. When arranging swaps, ensure the other author's audience aligns closely with yours for the best results.


Consider contributing to multi-author boxsets or anthologies. These compilations can reach a wide audience, and you can use them to promote your individual newsletter. Make sure your contribution includes a call-to-action for readers to join your list.


Participate in group promotions or giveaways with other authors in your genre. These events, often hosted on platforms like BookFunnel or StoryOrigin, allow multiple authors to pool their audiences and attract new subscribers.


Consider co-authoring a book or novella with another author in your genre. This can be an excellent way to cross-pollinate your audiences and attract new readers (and potential subscribers) to your work.


Remember, the key to successful author collaborations is mutual benefit. Look for opportunities where all parties stand to gain, and always deliver value to your partners and their audiences.


8. Running Contests and Giveaways


Contests and giveaways can rapidly boost your subscriber numbers by creating excitement and offering an incentive for signing up. Host regular giveaways offering prizes that will appeal to your target audience. These could include:


• Signed copies of your books

• Exclusive merchandise related to your books or writing

• Gift cards to bookstores

• E-readers

• Character naming rights in your next book


Use tools like KingSumo or Rafflecopter to manage entries efficiently. These platforms allow you to set up various entry methods, track participants, and randomly select winners.


Make newsletter subscription a requirement for entry. This ensures that everyone who participates joins your list. You can also offer bonus entries for additional actions like sharing the giveaway on social media, which helps spread the word and attract more participants.


To maximize participation, promote your giveaways widely:


• Announce them to your existing email list

• Share on all your social media platforms

• Post in relevant Facebook groups (with permission)

• List on giveaway sites like Goodreads Giveaways or LibraryThing Early Reviewers


When running contests or giveaways, be sure to comply with all relevant laws and platform rules. Some social media platforms have specific guidelines for promotions, so check these before launching your campaign.


After the giveaway, follow up with all new subscribers (not just the winners) with a welcome email. This helps build a connection and reduces the likelihood of people unsubscribing after the contest ends.


9. Paid Advertising for List Growth


While organic growth is ideal, paid advertising can give your list a significant boost, especially when you're just starting out or looking to reach a new audience. Here are some effective paid advertising strategies for growing your author newsletter:


Facebook Ads: Facebook's detailed targeting options allow you to reach readers interested in your specific genre or similar authors. Create ads with eye-catching images and compelling copy to promote your lead magnet. Consider using carousel ads to showcase multiple books or aspects of your newsletter.


When setting up your Facebook ads:

• Use the "Lead Generation" campaign objective to collect email addresses directly through Facebook

• Create a lookalike audience based on your current subscribers for better targeting

• Test different ad creatives and copy to see what resonates best with your audience


BookBub Ads: These ads appear on BookBub's website and in their emails, reaching a dedicated audience of book lovers. Use BookBub ads to target fans of authors similar to you, promoting your free lead magnet to attract sign-ups.


Tips for effective BookBub ads:

• Use high-quality book cover images in your ads

• Highlight any awards or bestseller status your books have achieved

• Include a clear call-to-action for joining your newsletter


Amazon Ads: While primarily used for promoting books, Amazon ads can also be used to grow your newsletter. Use Sponsored Brand ads to promote your author page, which should include a prominent link to your newsletter sign-up page.


For Amazon ads:

• Focus on relevant keywords related to your books and genre

• Use compelling ad copy that encourages readers to learn more about you as an author

• Ensure your author page is optimized with clear newsletter sign-up information


Other options to consider include:

• Goodreads ads for reaching dedicated readers

• Twitter ads, especially if you have an active presence on the platform

• LinkedIn ads if you write non-fiction or business-related books


When using paid advertising, start with a small budget and test different approaches. Monitor your results closely and calculate your cost per subscriber to ensure your advertising efforts remain cost-effective.


10. Crafting Engaging Newsletter Content


The key to a successful newsletter is engaging content that provides value to your subscribers. Your content should give readers a reason to open your emails eagerly and look forward to the next one. Here are some ideas for crafting compelling newsletter content:


Behind-the-scenes looks: Share insights into your writing process, research methods, or the inspiration behind your stories. Readers love feeling like they have insider access to their favorite authors.


Exclusive snippets or short stories: Offer content that can't be found anywhere else, such as previews of upcoming books, deleted scenes, or short stories featuring favorite characters.


Book recommendations: Share books you've enjoyed, especially those in your genre. This positions you as a knowledgeable voice in your field and provides value to readers always on the lookout for their next great read.


Personal updates: Share (appropriate) personal anecdotes or updates about your life. This helps readers feel connected to you as a person, not just an author.


Writing tips or industry insights: If appropriate for your audience, share writing advice or insights into the publishing industry. This can be particularly engaging for readers who are aspiring writers themselves.


Q&A sessions: Invite readers to submit questions and answer them in your newsletter. This interactive element can boost engagement and make readers feel heard.


Make your newsletters visually appealing by using images, GIFs, or even short videos to break up text. Ensure your design is clean and easy to read, with a clear hierarchy of information.


Personalization can significantly boost engagement. Use subscribers' names in the greeting and reference past interactions or purchases if possible. Many email service providers offer tools for easy personalization.


Always include clear calls-to-action (CTAs) in your newsletters. Whether it's to buy a book, leave a review, reply to a question, or check out a new blog post, make your CTAs clear and compelling.


Remember, consistency is key. Decide on a regular schedule for your newsletter – whether it's weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly – and stick to it. Let your subscribers know what to expect in terms of frequency and content.


11. Best Practices for Email Frequency and Timing


Finding the right email frequency is crucial for maintaining engagement without overwhelming your subscribers. There's no one-size-fits-all answer, as the ideal frequency can vary depending on your content, audience, and goals. However, here are some general guidelines:


Start with a monthly newsletter. This gives you enough time to gather meaningful content without taxing your schedule too heavily. As you grow more comfortable with creating newsletter content and gauge your audience's response, you can consider increasing frequency.


During book launch periods or when you have more news to share, you might temporarily increase your frequency. Just be sure to communicate this change to your subscribers so they're not surprised by the uptick in emails.


Consistency is key in newsletter marketing. Choose a schedule and stick to it. This helps set expectations for your subscribers and trains them to look for your emails at certain times.


The timing of your emails can also impact their effectiveness. While there's no universally perfect time to send emails, many authors find success with these general guidelines:


• Weekday evenings: Many people check their personal email after work

Weekend mornings: Readers may have more leisure time to engage with your content

• Midweek (Tuesday to Thursday): These days often see higher open rates than Mondays or Fridays


However, the best way to determine the optimal send time for your audience is through testing. Most email service providers allow you to A/B test different send times. Try sending your newsletter at different times and days of the week and monitor your open and click rates to see what works best for your specific audience.


Remember that your subscribers may be in different time zones. If you have a geographically diverse audience, consider using your email service provider's time zone sending feature. This ensures that your email arrives in each subscriber's inbox at the optimal time, regardless of their location.


Segmenting Your List for Better Engagement


Segmentation is a powerful strategy that can significantly improve your newsletter's effectiveness. By dividing your list into smaller groups based on specific criteria, you can tailor your content to better meet the needs and interests of different subscriber groups.


Here are some effective ways to segment your author newsletter:


By genre preference: If you write in multiple genres, segment your list accordingly. This allows you to send genre-specific content, promotions, and recommendations to the right audience.


By reading history: Create segments based on which of your books subscribers have purchased or shown interest in. This can inform your promotional strategies and help you provide more relevant content.


By engagement level: Identify your most engaged readers (those who consistently open and click your emails) and create a VIP segment. You can offer this group special perks, early access to new releases, or opportunities to beta read.


By signup source: Knowing where a subscriber joined your list (e.g., from your website, a specific book, or a giveaway) can help you understand their interests and tailor your content accordingly.


By location: If you have a geographically diverse audience, segmenting by location can be useful for promoting local events or adjusting content for cultural relevance.


To implement segmentation effectively:

- Use your email service provider's tagging or segmentation features to organize subscribers.

- Create targeted campaigns for different segments, ensuring the content is highly relevant to each group.

- Use segmentation to re-engage inactive subscribers with specialized content or offers.

- Regularly review and update your segments to ensure they remain accurate and useful.


Remember, the goal of segmentation is to provide more value to your subscribers by sending them content that's most relevant to their interests. This can lead to higher open rates, click-through rates, and overall engagement with your newsletter.


Analyzing Your Newsletter Metrics

Regular analysis of your newsletter metrics is crucial for ongoing improvement. By understanding how your subscribers interact with your emails, you can refine your strategy and create more effective campaigns. Here are the key metrics to track:


Open rate: This shows the percentage of subscribers who open your emails. In the publishing industry, a good open rate is typically between 20-30%. If your open rates are lower, consider testing different subject lines or sending times.


Click-through rate (CTR): This indicates the percentage of subscribers who clicked on a link in your email. A good CTR for authors is usually between 2-5%. Low CTRs might suggest that your content isn't compelling enough or that your calls-to-action aren't clear.


Unsubscribe rate: This shows how many people unsubscribe after receiving each email. Aim to keep this below 0.5% per email. A spike in unsubscribes might indicate that your content isn't meeting subscriber expectations or that you're emailing too frequently.


Conversion rate: This measures how many subscribers took a desired action (like purchasing a book or signing up for an event) after clicking a link in your email. This metric is crucial for understanding the effectiveness of your promotional efforts.


To improve your newsletter performance:

- Use A/B testing to experiment with different subject lines, content types, and email designs.

- Pay attention to which types of content generate the most engagement and create more of what works.

- Review your metrics regularly (monthly or quarterly) and adjust your strategy based on the data.

- Don't just focus on the numbers – also consider qualitative feedback from your subscribers.

- Most email service providers offer detailed analytics. Familiarize yourself with these tools and use them to gain insights into your newsletter's performance.


12. Maintaining List Hygiene


A clean email list is crucial for maintaining good deliverability rates and ensuring your messages reach your audience. Here are some best practices for maintaining list hygiene:


Regular cleaning: Remove invalid email addresses and bounced emails promptly. Most email service providers will automatically handle hard bounces, but keep an eye on soft bounces as well.


Handle inactive subscribers: Consider removing long-term inactive subscribers (those who haven't opened your emails in 6-12 months). However, before removing them, try a re-engagement campaign to win them back. This could involve sending a special offer or asking if they still want to hear from you.


Use double opt-in: Implement a double opt-in process where subscribers must confirm their email address before being added to your list. This ensures that all your subscribers genuinely want to receive your emails and helps prevent spam complaints.


Make unsubscribing easy: Always include a clear, easy-to-find unsubscribe link in every email. Honor unsubscribe requests promptly – it's not just good practice, it's the law in many jurisdictions.


Monitor your sender reputation: Use tools like SenderScore to keep an eye on your sender reputation. A good reputation ensures better deliverability of your emails.


Regularly update your list: Encourage subscribers to update their information if it changes. You might consider sending an annual "update your preferences" email.


By maintaining a clean list, you ensure that your emails are reaching engaged readers who want to hear from you. This can lead to better open rates, higher engagement, and a more effective newsletter overall.


13. Advanced Strategies for Rapid Growth


For authors looking to supercharge their list growth, consider these advanced strategies:


Create a referral program: Offer incentives for subscribers who refer new members to your list. This could include exclusive content, signed books, or even character naming rights in your next novel. Use tools like SparkLoop to manage referrals automatically.


Develop a free email course: Create a 5-7 day email course related to your books' themes or the craft of writing. This can attract subscribers interested in deeper content and showcase your expertise, particularly other authors or aspiring writers.


Guest blogging: Write guest posts for popular blogs in your genre. Include a bio with a link to your newsletter sign-up page to capture interested readers.


Podcast appearances: When you appear as a guest on podcasts related to your genre or writing, offer listeners a special lead magnet to encourage sign-ups.


Host virtual events: Consider hosting online book clubs, writing workshops, or Q&A sessions. Require newsletter sign-up for attendance to grow your list while providing value to your audience.


Create a community space: Develop a members-only area (like a private Facebook group or a dedicated forum on your website) exclusively for your newsletter subscribers. This can increase engagement and encourage word-of-mouth promotion.


Implement content upgrades: Create specific lead magnets for individual blog posts or book pages on your website. These targeted offers can be highly effective in converting casual readers into subscribers.



Building a thriving author newsletter takes time, effort, and consistent attention. But the rewards are well worth it. A strong mailing list gives you a direct line to your most engaged readers, a powerful platform for book launches, and a community of supporters who are invested in your author journey.

Remember, it's not just about the numbers. While growing your list is important, engaging with your subscribers and providing value is equally crucial. Focus on building genuine connections with your readers, and your newsletter will become an invaluable asset to your author career.

Start implementing these strategies today, and watch your author newsletter transform from a simple mailing list into a vibrant, engaged community of readers who are eager to support your work and spread the word about your books.


Happy writing, and happy newsletter building!

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page